The shaking scoop was the point, not a flaw. On some Ford Mustang Mach 1s, the air intake was mounted to the engine rather than the hood, so it moved as the engine vibrated. Protruding through an opening in the hood, the scoop made machinery visible where most cars kept it hidden.
The movement served a purpose beyond theater. The Shaker scoop drew outside air toward the carburetor, giving the engine an alternative to the hotter air under the hood. Cooler air is denser, which can help combustion by supplying more oxygen for a given volume. At speed, ram pressure could also assist airflow into the intake, although the gain depended on driving conditions and the rest of the engine setup. It was no magic horsepower switch.
The design traded discretion for access. Because the scoop moved with the engine, the hood opening had to accommodate that motion without making the scoop part of the hood itself. Not every Mach 1 carried this arrangement; equipment varied by configuration. Against the fastback roofline and dark hood treatment associated with the model, the exposed intake turned an engineering compromise into a feature. At idle, the hood stayed still while the engine announced itself through the opening.